Amendment One Conversations Continue Across Iowa

30-Second Summary:

  1. Amendment One would protect all Iowa taxpayers by requiring a two-thirds vote of both chambers of the legislature to increase income tax rates. It would make tax increases more difficult, but not impossible.
  2. Other states have demonstrated that supermajority requirements work. These protections encourage broader agreement on tax increases while still allowing lawmakers flexibility to respond to changing financial circumstances.
  3. Amendment One would build on Iowa’s recent tax reforms by encouraging greater spending discipline and requiring lawmakers to prioritize government spending before asking taxpayers for more money.

Whether in southwest Iowa, northeast Iowa, or anywhere in between, the question before voters remains the same: Should it be more difficult for politicians to take more of your money?  Iowans for Tax Relief Foundation continued its efforts to educate voters about Amendment One this week, traveling to opposite corners of the state for conversations with taxpayers in Mills County in southwest Iowa and Buchanan County in northeast Iowa.

Amendment One, which will appear on the November 3 ballot, would require a two-thirds vote of both the Iowa House and Iowa Senate before lawmakers could increase income tax rates.  The amendment would not prohibit an income tax increase. Instead, it would require lawmakers to build a broader consensus before taking more of Iowans’ income.

In Mills County, much of the conversation focused on what Amendment One would and would not do. The amendment would not automatically reduce income taxes, require spending cuts, or change how Iowa funds education and health care. Nor would it increase property or sales taxes, or create special tax credits, deductions, or exemptions.

Instead, Amendment One would establish a straightforward taxpayer protection.   No matter how much someone earns, the legislature would face the same two-thirds requirement before increasing the income tax rate that applies to that taxpayer. The same protection would extend to businesses, from small family operations to large corporations.

The discussion also highlighted that supermajority requirements are hardly a new concept. From passing legislation in the United States Senate to approving local bond measures, higher voting thresholds already exist throughout government. These requirements recognize that certain decisions should require broader agreement than a simple majority.

In Buchanan County, we met with Iowans at the Independence Pizza Ranch, where the conversation turned to the experience of other states and the importance of controlling government spending.  Numerous states, representing a wide range of political perspectives, have operated under supermajority tax requirements for decades. Their experience demonstrates that such protections make tax increases more difficult, but not impossible. Lawmakers in these states have continued to raise taxes when they have assembled the necessary votes.

Another question addressed in Independence was how Iowa would respond to an economic emergency if Amendment One were adopted.

Iowa’s own history offers an important lesson. During the Great Recession, the state faced significant budget challenges but responded by reducing spending and using reserve funds rather than increasing income tax rates. That experience demonstrates that increasing taxes is not the only option available to lawmakers facing difficult financial circumstances.

More importantly, it reinforces the relationship between government spending and taxation. When spending grows faster than available revenue, lawmakers face increasing pressure to raise taxes. Controlling spending is one of the most effective ways to avoid that pressure in the first place.

That lesson is particularly relevant as other states confront budget shortfalls and pursue tax increases. States such as Washington and New York are examples of places that turned to tax increases to keep up with their spending increases.

Amendment One would not impose a direct limit on government spending. However, by making income tax increases more difficult, it would encourage lawmakers to exercise greater discipline, establish priorities, and justify the need for additional revenue before asking taxpayers to pay more.

The Buchanan County discussion also provided an opportunity to reflect on Iowa’s progress in tax reform.

In 2018, Iowa’s top individual income tax rate was 8.98%, while its top corporate rate was 12%. Since then, lawmakers have enacted several rounds of tax reform, moving to a flat 3.8% individual income tax rate, eliminating taxes on retirement income, phasing out the inheritance tax, and reducing corporate income tax rates.  These changes have helped make Iowa’s tax system more competitive. Amendment One would build on that progress by establishing a higher threshold for future income tax rate increases.

Ultimately, the conversations in Mills and Buchanan counties reinforced the same principle: Raising income taxes should not be an easy decision.

Amendment One would not prevent future legislatures from responding to emergencies, funding essential services, or making difficult budget decisions. It would simply require broader agreement before increasing income taxes. As Iowans prepare to vote on November 3, these conversations provide an opportunity to better understand what Amendment One would do and the taxpayer protections it would establish.

 Print a PDF