Property Does Not Exist to Support Government
Supreme Court Clarifies Tax Sale Rights: In Pung v. Isabella County, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that taxpayers are entitled to the surplus proceeds from a tax sale—but not the fair market value of their property if it later sells for more. “Nothing Less, and Nothing More”: Building on its 2023 Tyler decision, the Court reaffirmed that governments may collect unpaid taxes through a tax sale, but may retain only what is owed and must return any surplus to the former property owner. Property Rights Still Matter: While concurring in the judgment, Justice Clarence Thomas emphasized that property rights are fundamental and argued that the Constitution places strict limits on the government’s power to take private property, reminding officials that “the government exists to protect property; property does not exist to support the government.”